For arthritis of the hand, how does a doctor determine if surgery is necessary?

Doctor's Answers 1

Photo of Dr Aaron Gan
Dr Aaron Gan

Hand Surgeon

Arthritis in the hand can be categorised into 2 main types:

1. Degenerative or osteoarthritis

2. Inflammatory arthritis such as psoriatic arthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, septic arthritis and gouty arthritis

Of the two, degenerative or osteoarthritis is the more common type. Osteoarthritis is simply the premature wear of the cartilage surfaces in a joint and can be primary or secondary.

Primary causes of osteoarthritis can be either from age-related degeneration or excessive wear and tear from repeated overuse of the particular joint. Secondary causes include previous injury to the joint or developmental abnormalities causing deformities in the joint.

Any of the multiple joints in the hand can become osteoarthritic. The most common of the hand joints to develop osteoarthritis are:

  • 1st carpometacarpal joint, also known as the thumb basal joint
  • Distal interphalangeal joints of the fingers
  • Proximal interphalangeal joints of the fingers

The metacarpophalangeal joints are rarely involved in osteoarthritis.

The main symptom of osteoarthritis is pain. The pain is usually worse with motion at the joint and is relieved with immobilisation and resting of the joint. Often times, the pain in the joint is not consistent and may flare and abate unpredictably.

A hand surgeon will assess the patient comprehensively to diagnose the type of arthritis afflicting the joint in the presenting patient. This will include:

  • Full medical history
  • A detailed clinical examination followed by radiological investigations such as X-rays, CT-scans or MRI scans
  • Blood investigations may be necessary if the doctor suspects inflammatory arthritis.

The principles of treating osteoarthritis in the hand are similar to that of the other joints in the body:

1. Non-surgical treatments to reduce loading of the joint, diminish swelling, control pain and prevent further degeneration. These include:

  • Activity modification
  • Splinting with custom-moulded rigid splints or over-the-counter braces
  • Oral medications such as non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS), joint supplements such as glucosamine and complementary anti-inflammatory agents such as ginger or turmeric supplements
  • Intra-articular injections of corticosteroids (strong anti-inflammatory agents) or viscoelastic preparations such as hyaluronic acids

2. Surgical treatments including the following options:

  • Arthroscopic surgery (key-hole surgery) to debride (clean up) the joint of all inflammatory tissue
  • Joint balancing procedures involving cutting bone, adjusting angles of the joint and fixation using metal implants
  • Arthroplasty (joint-moulding) procedures including:

i. Excisional arthroplasty (removal of the painful joint) with or without additional procedures to stabilize the related bones

ii. Interpositional arthroplasty (joint-cushioning procedures) using the patient’s own tissue (usually tendon grafts) to cushion the worn-out cartilage and relieve pain

iii. Replacement arthroplasty involving the removal of the natural joint and replacing it with an artificial joint implant

The surgeon usually exhausts all non-surgical options before offering surgical treatments. Surgery is indicated when the individual continues to experience pain in the joint despite all the non-surgical options. The type of surgery will also depend on the grade and severity of the osteoarthritis and the expected function of the joint post-surgery.

Similar Questions

How can one resolve knee pain even after a knee replacement surgery?

Thank you for your question. Persistent severe pain after a right knee replacement is abnormal especially when her other knee replacement was doing fine. I'd strongly advise you bring your grandmom for a checkup and we'll need to do a thorough investigations including X rays, blood tests and advanced imaging (MRI/ CT) to find out what is the cause of this persistent pain. The cause of persistent pain would include infection, implant malposition, cement fracture or referred pain. Only after the cause of the persistent pain is identified then we can talk about the treatment.

Photo of Dr Henry Chan

Answered By

Dr Henry Chan

Orthopaedic Surgeon

What is the cause for sore and stiff fingers, and which specialist should I see in Singapore?

The most common cause of the symptoms described is trigger finger. Trigger finger is a condition where the tendons controlling flexion of the digit become inflamed and swollen. As these tendons glide in and out within a fitting tunnel called a tendon sheath, any increase in girth of these tendons can disrupt the smooth gliding action. Trigger finger is categorized into 4 grades. Grade 1 trigger finger: Initially, the additional friction from the swelling of the tendons cause pain when moving the finger.

Photo of Dr Aaron Gan

Answered By

Dr Aaron Gan

Hand Surgeon

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox