Need COVID-19 guidance? Check out our latest resources

Is the fractional radiofrequency, CO2 laser or erbium laser more effective for deep acne scars?

  • Answered3 times
  • Viewed2,844 times

Doctor’s Answer (3)

With regards to your question:

  1. Fractional CO2 lasers generally penetrates deeper than Erbium lasers
  2. Fractional CO2 lasers also generally penetrates deeper than Fractional RF devices EXCEPT Microneedle RF machines that can reach a depth of 3.5mm (only in some machines) which in this case will have a greater penetration depth as compared to Fractional CO2 machines.

Fractional CO2 lasers also generate more heat than Erbium lasers and as such have better collagen synthesis etc but this also confers a higher risk of heat-related side effects namely Post-Inflammation Hyperpigmentation (PIH) , redness and longer downtime.

As the other doctors have mentioned, this is where Fractional RF machines have a safer side effect profile with a lower risk of PIH.

That being said, one would also have to consider the type of acne scars you have as different scars are treated differently and not all scars respond well to machine-led treatments.

In conclusion, all these devices have their pros and cons, and can deliver good results when executed to its full potential.

Hope that helps.

All the best!

The current options for ablative treatment of acne scars would be mostly limited to :

  1. Fractional Co2 laser
  2. Fractional Erbium laser
  3. Fractional RF

I would say that for easy understanding, fractional CO2 has the best results because it is able to penetrate deeper into the skin. However, it’s a double edged sword and has much higher chances of side effects like PIH ( Post-Inflammatory Hyperpigmentation) and Hypopigmentation.

Fractional Erbium and Fractional RF were developed precisely because of the higher chances of those side effects, and thus they do not penetrate as deep or ablate as strongly. However, they still give a good result with much lower chances of side effects.

Thus, your idea that fractional RF goes deeper than fractional CO2 is likely not true, based on the above principles.

To help you decide, mainly you need to think through the following factors :

  1. Are you still having active acne? If yes, you will need treatment for that first. There’s no point treating the scars if you are still having active acne. It’s like trying to fill a bucket of water to the brim but the bottom has a hole continuously leaking. You need to plug the hole first. There are many options and if your keen to find out more, you can send another question on DXD.
  2. How much downtime can you afford? The deeper the laser, the longer the downtime and the more conscientious you need to be with your post-laser recovery. You’ll need to apply more recovery products as well.
  3. Are you willing to take the risks of PIH/Hypopigmentation ? This is more pronounced if you have a darker skin type. There are always risks with every medical treatment.
  4. Cost

Hope that helps!

In a nutshell:

  1. Fractional CO2 gives the best improvement but is frequently not tolerated in out context because of prolonged downtime and high risk of side effects such as PIH.
  2. Fractional radio frequency (RF) was invented for this purpose – much safer profile for Asian skin and supposedly less effective.
  3. However, because it is safer to use Fractional RF at a higher power setting, some doctors actually get better results than the CO2 (which would be undesirable or unsafe to use at higher setting)
  4. There are two forms of Fractional Erbium – the Erbium Yag and Erbium Glass. The Yag laser is ablative whereas the Glass laser is non ablative.
  5. The fractional Erbium Glass laser was shown on a clinical study to have better results than the Fractional RF for scarring. Similarly, it is also much safer for Asian skin types and offers even less downtime.

Hope this was helpful!

Not the answer you're looking for? Just ask your own question now FOR FREE.

Read This Next
A Complete Guide To Laser And Skin Treatments In Singapore (2020)

Lasers have become an indispensable part of the aesthetic industry, with some beauty salons even importing and operating them without a license.

If you're trying to find a proper laser treatment for your skin condition, this guide will give you the complete low-down of available laser and skin treatments in Singapore.

An Aesthetic Doctor Reviews Acne Scar Removal Treatments in Singapore (2020)

"Doctor with interest in Aesthetics and Lasers"

Dealing with acne in your youth is bad enough, but the scars left behind can be a real nightmare.

New patients often ask me 2 common questions:

  • “I’ve tried one laser session before. Why don’t I see results yet?”
  • “I still have acne scars and uneven skin texture despite 10 sessions of chemical peels. Why?”

This is why I have decided to write this article to help those of you who are struggling with acne scars. The best outcomes usually result from a combination of different methods, individualised to your skin type and scar! Here's what you need to know. 

Treating Rolling Acne And Box Scars: A Doctor Shares Tips

Acne is not just a passing condition. Long after the acne is gone, scars in a variety of shapes and forms can emerge. Some common scar types experienced by patients include box and rolling acne scars. Fortunately, there are specific treatments and methods that can help improve the appearance of skin with box and rolling acne scars, which a DoctorxDentist reader asked about recently.

With expertise in threadlift procedures and acne scar treatments, Dr Ho Rui Ming serves as the medical director of M-Aesthetic Clinic. On DoctorxDentist, he shed light on the most effective ways to deal with acne scars. Here are our key takeaways.

All You Need To Know About Hormonal Acne: A Singaporean Aesthetic Doctor Explains

Acne… oh, acne… It can be super frustrating as it really affects our appearance.

Hormonal acne can affect anyone at any age. It is named as such because changes in our hormone levels can cause it. You may be wondering how hormonal acne can be treated. For instance, you may be considering:

  • home remedies,
  • OTC creams or 
  • medical treatments.

Read on to find out in more detail how you can get hormonal acne treated!

The Ultimate Guide to Fractional Lasers by an Aesthetic Doctor in Singapore (2020)

Having smooth skin that is free of acne scars and wrinkles is the dream of many. There is little we will not do to achieve skin that becomes the envy of others.

As an aesthetic doctor who specialises in customised laser treatments, I have written this article about fractional lasers to help guide you in choosing which fractional laser treatment works best for you. 

Request Quotes From Doctors

Based on your requirements, we will recommend up to 5 expert medical doctors.

Get Treatment Quotes
Related Questions
A multimodal approach is often needed to remove acne scars. These can include: subcision TCA CROSS and punch excision with microsurgery apart from laser treatments Acne scars can be depressed or raised, with or without discoloration. ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, You have deep ice-pick scars. These deep scars are best dealt with in 2 stages. The first stage involves converting the deep scars to shallower scars. Scar excision and TCA cross are methods to achieve this. The second stage involves ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, The most important age factor to consider when to undergo acne scar treatment is not the age per say but when the acne is no longer active. This is because continued active acne will result in new scars and undo the benefits of the acne ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, Acne marks (post-inflammatory erythema and hyperpigmentation) will gradually fade on their own over several weeks/months, so do not worry. It is important to prevent new acne from occurring (check out the Acne section for the various ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, The key principle of acne scar treatment is “controlled injury” to the dermis where the acne scar tissue is located. This controlled injury to the dermis allows for subsequent healing to occur, laying down new and more organized collagen ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, The key principle of acne scar treatment is “controlled injury” to the dermis where the acne scar tissue are located. This controlled injury to the dermis allows for subsequent healing to occur, laying down new and more organized collagen ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, All current treatment for acne scars will also work for dark ethnic skin although risk of PIH is higher if you opt for more aggressive/effective modalities which can give you greater clinical improvement.  Fractional CO2 laser can be ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

Hi, Scar remodeling and collagen stimulating procedures as listed by you will work just as well in older and more mature patients. In addition, older patients undergoing such resurfacing procedures will benefit from improvement in fine lines, ... Read Full Answer

"Dedicated to the ethical practice of Aesthetic Medicine"

In fact, yes. Fractional CO2 lasering is associated with mild flare of acne in 10% of the patients. Especially in patients who are still getting occasional acne before the laser treatment. However, subsequent acne flares can be minimised with ... Read Full Answer
You have a combination of scar types and will benefit most from a carefully selected series of treatments that include TCA Cross, lasers (ablative and picosecond fractional forms), with or without fractional radiofrequency treatments and ... Read Full Answer