Is it safe to undergo surgery for multi-focal intraocular lens (IOL) if I have previously undergone one for mono-focal IOLs?

Doctor's Answers 2

It depends a little bit on what is meant by safe. Technically speaking, the surgery is just the same whether a multi- or mono-focal lens is used, with the same very low risk of complications.

The question rather, is - can you get used to the different visual experience between the 2 eyes?

So the original eye with a mono-focal lens will see very clearly at one distance. At other distances it is somewhat blurry unless you wear the necessary glasses.

If you get a multi-focal lens in the other eye, you will notice differences between the eyes, some of which are more obvious than others.

1. The eye with a (diffractive) multi-focal lens will see rings around light sources at night (or when the background is dark).

2. Without glasses, things are clearer at different distances with the multifocal lens.

3. With glasses, things could feel a bit sharper at the focal distance of the monofocal lens, because the monofocal lens is always going to give better contrast at its focal distance compared with the multifocal lens.

Generally speaking, having a monofocal in one eye and a multifocal in the other eye is not encouraged, because many people are likely to find it difficult to get used to the different feelings between the 2 eyes. If they cannot get used to it, a second surgery to replace the multi-focal with a mono-focal lens would be necessary.

Photo of Dr E-Shawn Goh
Dr E-Shawn Goh

Ophthalmologist

There are several parts to this question:

  1. Yes. It is safe to undergo such surgery as it is in a separate eye. It will have no bearing on surgery that was performed in the other eye.
  2. If you are asking about replacing a monofocal IOL with a multi-focal IOL, this is safely performed by a surgeon with sufficient experience and skin in intraocular procedures. Do ask your attending Ophthalmologist what his/her experiences in such procedures are.
  3. If you are considering placing a multifocal IOL in one eye (if the contralateral eye has a mono-focal IOL), then this is not usually recommended by the IOL manufacturers. However this has been performed not uncommonly, and even the results are published widely. Ultimately whether the patient accepts this combination of IOL is up to the individual. You should make this decision in close consideration with your attending Ophthalmologist.

Thankfully, see answer 2) if necessary - it is possible to explant an IOL in order to replace it with another type, if so required.

Similar Questions

Statistically, which LASIK procedure has the least likelihood of residual degree after the surgery?

There is as far as I know, no reliable statistical data to allow a definitive answer to this question. By this, I mean there are no well conducted, randomised blinded controlled trials comparing different procedures with respect to residual refractive error. As I mentioned in another answer, a Cochrane Database meta-analysis showed similarly good outcomes between LASIK and PRK at one year, but this is in no way a 'statistical' validation of their equality.

Photo of Human

Answered By

Human

Why do Multifocal lenses after cataract surgery cost more but result in poorer vision for both short and long distances when compared to Monofocal lenses?

There are several aspects to consider in answering this question. Firstly, there is no cure for presbyopia/'Lao Hua', which refers to the loss of autofocusing ability of the eye. There are no cures, there are only compromises. That is why, in order to get relatively good vision for far and near, some compromises have to be made for the contrast at a particular distance when compared to monofocal lenses. But then again, you have to consider what you mean by 'poorer'.

Photo of Human

Answered By

Human

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox