What are the main benefits of having early cataract surgery, as opposed to delaying treatment since it is an elective procedure?

Doctor's Answers 2

'Early' is a subjective term, and can mean different things to different people.

The real question is: is the cataract affecting your vision, and by how much?

A very early 'cataract' may not affect vision at all. In this case, the only possible benefit of doing the operation is the possibility of refractive correction-the procedure becomes like LASIK and only aims to reduce spectacle power. In this case, there is no difference between wearing glasses/contact lenses and having the surgery, for older people. For younger people less than 40 years of age, doing this kind of surgery (lens replacement) may even feel like a worse situation because they immediately get full presbyopia.

The more a cataract is affecting vision, the greater the visual improvement that will be perceived after surgery and the better the risk versus benefit ratio. You could say it is a good thing to delay surgery until a cataract reaches such a density that the visual blurring it causes starts to bother the patient.

So let's assume another scenario, where the cataract is already affecting vision significantly and the patient is pondering whether to do it now or 6 months later.

The situation becomes clearer if you think of this analogy: Someone has a pair of glasses with badly scratched and hazy lenses. What happens if he changes his glasses now, versus 6 months later?

So if someone already has a significant cataract, getting it done earlier will give faster recovery of vision, and avoid the frustration of having to put up with blurry vision for some arbitrary period of time. Or you could also look at it this way-you are going to go through the process of surgery anyway, so why put up with the blurriness any longer than you have to?

For certain groups of people, such as those with weak corneal endothelial cells, it may also be better to do it earlier rather than later because a milder, softer cataract requires less ultrasound energy to emulsify, and so may help these people preserve the remaining endothelial cells better. To some extent, this is also true of other people without endothelial problems, however, it would take a pretty dense/hard cataract to trouble most surgeons in people with normal corneas.

Also, an extremely dense, hypermature cataract could give rise to other problems like inflammation or rises in eye pressure, though in Singapore it is very rare to encounter cases like these nowadays.

Photo of Dr E-Shawn Goh
Dr E-Shawn Goh

Ophthalmologist

Moden cataract surgery has advanced to the point that it is a highly predictable, efficient and safe procedure that is performed quickly and comfortably for patients.

This is in addition to the fact that modern lens calculators, microscopes, surgical equipment and implants have allowed us to consistently and accurately predict the post-operative refractive status for most patients.

Hence if any patient (in the absence of any other significant risk factors) begins to experience the negative effects of a cloudy cataractous lens, including:

  • blurred vision
  • fluctuating lens power
  • loss of color contrast
  • reduced night vision

then they should consider cataract surgery.

Cataract surgery can effectively and safely treat the cause of the problems, and often times with an appropriate intraocular lens choice, may allow patients to be spectacle independent for the first time in their lives!

Do discuss your options in detail with your attending ophthalmologist who would be able to discuss these options in detail.

E-Shawn Goh

Similar Questions

When should I have cataract surgery, and what will happen if my cataracts are not removed?

Cataract surgery is not always an elective procedure. Occasionally, a cataract may progress very rapidly to cause severe visual impairment, as well as acute glaucoma. In these situations, the cataract needs to be removed urgently. In most other cases, cataract surgery is elective because cataract progression is usually very gradual. You should choose to have your cataracts removed when your vision deteriorates to a stage that it affects your quality of life. This is very dependent on each individual, your occupation and activities you like to do.

Photo of Dr Claudine Pang

Answered By

Dr Claudine Pang

Ophthalmologist

What are the most common reasons for cataract surgery in Singapore?

The most common causes of cataracts are: Age – We will all develop a cataract when we get older. It’s a matter of how severe the cataract is and whether our vision is impaired by it, that determines whether or not we need surgery. Excessive sunlight exposure – We know that ultraviolet rays from sunlight exposure is a major risk factor for cataract formation. Hence, with cumulative exposure to sunlight without proper UV protection, we will need cataract surgery sooner than most.

Photo of Dr Claudine Pang

Answered By

Dr Claudine Pang

Ophthalmologist

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox