When does a microdiscectomy need to be repeated for a slipped disc?

Doctor's Answers 1

Photo of Dr Shee Yan Fong
Dr Shee Yan Fong

Orthopaedic Surgeon

Microdiscectomy is the standard surgical procedure commonly performed when a disc needs to be removed usually because it is endangering a nearby spinal cord or nerve (e.g. if patient has worsening sciatica pain in his leg unable to walk).

It combines both the advantages of physical removal of the herniated disc out of the spine (unlike radiofrequency discoplasty "injection") with minimally invasive approach reducing risk of collateral damage, pain, bleeding and infection because of a smaller incision wound, enabling patient rapid recovery (early return to home and work) after microdiscectomy.

With these benefits follow the disadvantage of not able to remove 100% of the disc (at least 10% may remain - ironically also helping to preserve some motion), unlike a larger fusion surgery which necessitates complete 100% disc (and motion) removal before implant insertion.

Hence 10% risk of a recurrent/relapse re-prolapse of the remnant disc anytime in the future is always made known to all patients during their consent process before their first microdiscectomy surgery.

A relapse of his old preoperative sciatica confirmed by a repeat mri of a recurrent same disc herniation will warn of this complication.

Similar to his first episode, a repeat discectomy or even fusion surgery is necessary if this second episode cannot be controlled by conservative treatment. The most important prevention is to make sure the wound and back/neck recover as much as possible after the first surgery and rehab postop spinal physio done for core strengthening after the first surgery.

An important recent development is the use of a newer endoscopic discectomy surgery as an alternative to microdiscectomy (can even be done by a pain specialist who is not even a surgeon!).

Because of a now even smaller endoscopic access, more and more cases of recurrent disc herniation necessitating a repeat surgery have been reported in USA so patients/doctors please beware !

Similar Questions

How can you tell the difference between a lower back muscle strain and a herniated disc?

Thanks for your question. This is very important as often people are diagnosed with muscular back pain and turn out to have a disc problem and vice versa. The reason is that is can be very difficult to differentiate the different causes of back pain as there can often be quite an overlap. In situations with a disc or nerve problem, the lower back muscles can become tight and go into spasm. Equally, with a muscle pull in the back, there can be pain shooting I tot he legs etc.

Photo of Dr Dinesh Sirisena

Answered By

Dr Dinesh Sirisena

Sport Medicine

What should I do next for lower back pain that occured on running?

Thank you for your questions. I agreed with both Dr. Sean and Dr. Dinesh that your pain is likely "discogenic", meaning that it is coming from the disc, which is the cushion in between the bones. There are also a spectrum of a "slipped disc", only when the slipped disc is very severe and compressing onto the nerve then you will develop tingling sensation or sciatica. Of course we don't want to wait until then before we do a thorough checkup on you, I'd recommend a MRI scan for you to investigate the actual cause of the pain and the severity of the condition.

Photo of Dr Henry Chan

Answered By

Dr Henry Chan

Orthopaedic Surgeon

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox