Why does laser treatment work if it damages the skin and collagen, similar to smoking?

Doctor's Answers 2

Do not fret that you felt no improvement after laser treatments. Medical lasers do work - it is just that the right lasers have to be selected for the skin condition that the patient want to address.

There may be some misconceptions about the topic of skin, collagen and breakdown. To answer your question broadly, the way smoking damages the skin is very different from the way lasers or other energy devices ‘damage’ the skin.

Smoking damages the skin in many ways, including destroying collagen, while some laser procedures which aim to build up collagen may involve damaging the skin surface.

Smoking

A puff of cigarette smoke contains a few thousands free oxygen radicals. These free radicals are hyper-reactive oxygen atoms that can wreak havoc in our various body tissues and organs. Besides harming our health, free radicals can damage our skin in the following ways:

  • Direct damage to collagen. Collagen fibrils in our skin can be directly damaged by oxygen free radicals. These collagen fibrils are an important component of our skin’s extracellular matrix, which determines the integrity and function of the skin dermis.
  • Impaired production. Fibroblasts, the main cells responsible for producing new collagen in our skin, will be modified by the free radicals and result in a much reduced collagen production capacity (up to 40% in studies).
  • Amplification of damage. Free radicals are highly reactive, meaning that they can self-perpetuate reactions that they initiated. Studies have also shown that increased degradation of collagen induces more oxidative stress, worsening the direct damage on collagen (point 1), and causes increased protein oxidation of fibroblasts (point 2). [1]

Lasers and energy devices

On the flip side, laser effect of the skin is determined by what we call the selective photothermolysis effect. In short, what this means is:

  • Lasers have specific wavelengths, which we can utilize to treat specific skin conditions
  • In terms of collagen, some of the devices we can use include:
  1. Traditional CO2 laser
  2. 2940nm Erbium:YAG laser
  3. 1550nm Erbium Glass Laser
  • These lasers can target the collagen fibrils in our skin
  • They stimulate production of collagen, cause thermal contraction of the dermis, thereby causing skin tightening.

Point to note is that the ‘damage’ that we see in laser treatments is frequently due to the destruction of the epidermis (the top layer of the skin) and upper part of the dermis (second layer of the skin).

Finally, lasers, if done right, do work. If you feel that your laser did not address your concern, it is best to speak with your doctor again.

Hope that helps.

Warmest regards

Dr Heng Wee Soon

[1] Fisher GJ, Quan T, Purohit T, et al. Collagen Fragmentation Promotes Oxidative Stress and Elevates Matrix Metalloproteinase-1 in Fibroblasts in Aged Human Skin. The American Journal of Pathology. 2009;174(1):101-114. doi:10.2353/ajpath.2009.080599.

Photo of Dr Joanna Chan
Dr Joanna Chan

Aesthetic, General Practitioner

Thank you for your question, and giving us the opportunity to clarify some concepts about lasers.

In essence, the biomolecular pathways by which smoking (toxic components and carcinogens in cigarette smoke, in fact) and laser act on your skin are very different.

Smoking:

1. The compounds in cigarette smoke reduces the rate at which your body produces collagen, due to its effect on fibroblasts (the collagen-producing cells in your body) - by up to 40% (1).

2. Cigarette smoke also increases the amount of collagen-destroying enzymes in the skin - leading to collagen damage (1).

3. Smoking reduces the amount of anti-oxidants (such as vitamin C) in the body, which contribute to cell and collagen damage and ageing/lax skin.

Laser:

1. Studies have shown that laser treatments led to marked improvements in dermal layer thickness and collagen fiber density, and the increase in fibroblast number (2). The lasers studied in this particular study include the 595nm pulsed dye laser (PDL), 1320nm NdYAG and 1064nm NdYAG (QS) lasers (this is also one of the most common lasers done in Singapore).

2. The collagen remodeling was still present after 3 months and confirms the long-term effect of the laser treatment.

3. The amount of new collagen synthesis correlated with the amount of thermal damage (for laser resurfacing procedures) (3).

I am sorry that you did not see good improvement after your previous laser sessions; there could be some contributing factors and explanations for these and I suggest you talk to your trusted doctor more regarding which treatments may be more suitable for you.

Best regards,

Dr. Joanna Chan

References:

1. Knuutinen A. et al. Smoking affects collagen synthesis and extracellular matrix turnover in human skin. Br J Dermatol. 2002 Apr;146(4):588-94.

2. Liu H. et al. Laser induced collagen remodeling: a comparative study in vivo on mouse model. Lasers Surg Med. 2008 Jan;40(1)

3. Longo C. et al. Laser skin rejuvenation: epidermal changes and collagen remodeling evaluated by in vivo confocal microscopy. Lasers Med Sci. 2013 May;28(3):769-76.

Similar Questions

How effective is fractional Co2 laser vs Infini RF for acne scars?

Good questions! I agree with Dr Chua’s reply on the pros and cons of Fractional CO2 lasers versus Infini RF. In addition, I would like to address your question on the ideal length of time between subcision and Infini RF treatments. The ideal interval between treatments is 4-6 weeks. This is to allow for adequate skin recovery. Hope that this answers your questions!

Photo of Human

Answered By

Human

Is PRP injection available for acne scarring in Singapore?

PRP at the present moment is not available in Singapore. It does help with acne scarring though, and you might have to go to neighbouring countries to do the treatment (including Malaysia). Having said that, you can consider Rejuran/skin boosters/microneedling that can help in a similar fashion. Your 2nd question on which is better — it depends on the severity and type of scars. But usually Fractional laser is the backbone of laser therapy. So consult your doctor early to discuss the available options.

Photo of Dr Winston  Lee

Answered By

Dr Winston Lee

Aesthetic

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox