What kind of risks does a patient get exposed to when undergoing open surgery compared to keyhole surgery?

Doctor's Answers 1

Photo of Dr Yuk Man Kan
Dr Yuk Man Kan

General Surgeon

Open surgery requires a big cut to be made, and the surgeon has to reach into your body to cut the parts out. For keyhole surgery, incisions are made and instruments reach into your body to make the cuts rather than a surgeon’s hands. In that sense, keyhole surgery is a much harder surgery to perform.

But the main thing is to make sure that we get rid of all the cancer. So technically the risk of keyhole surgery depends on the difficulty in finding the angle to cut the stomach out and doing the surgery in a confined space compared to open surgery. Open surgery is easier, I’ve been doing it for a long time.

Keyhole surgery is harder and takes longer, probably an extra 1-2 hours. So the risk is that the surgery is slightly longer for the patient. But bear in mind that open surgery requires a big cut, so the overall risk is still lower for keyhole surgery. If you get someone who’s not very experienced in doing keyhole surgery then that’s where the concern is.

That’s when the practice and experience come into play -- in the sense that big cancers can still be operated on with keyhole surgery, that’s the main advantage. Blood loss is lower, recovery is much faster, the risk of other complications such as infections are lower.

Similar Questions

For carpal tunnel syndrome, when is open surgery preferred over minimally invasive surgery (endoscopic), and what are the considerations?

Open surgery is preferred over endoscopic surgery in carpal tunnel syndrome in the following conditions: Revision carpal tunnel release requiring neurolysis of the median nerve and transposing an ulnarly-based fat pad flap over the median nerve. End-stage carpal tunnel syndrome requiring a tendon transfer to restore thumb abduction function due to complete paralysis of the abductor pollicis brevis muscle. These procedures are more complex and require proper exposure of the median nerve. In straightforward carpal tunnel syndrome, either method will yield similar results.

Photo of Dr Aaron Gan

Answered By

Dr Aaron Gan

Hand Surgeon

How do I prevent a keloid after an open heart surgery from getting bigger?

Thank you for the question about a keloid after open heart surgery. These are very commonly seen and can be controlled with a combination treatment of VBEAM laser and steroid injections into the scar. Early treatment of your scar will lead to better results and helps to prevent scar worsening. Depending on the size and thickness of your scar, repeated 4-5 treatments 1 month apart are usually required to flatten and lighten the scar. Do see a doctor or dermatologist experienced in scar treatment for help.

Photo of Dr Stephanie  Ho

Answered By

Dr Stephanie Ho

Dermatologist

Ask any health question for free

I’m not so sure about a procedure...

Ask Icon Ask a Question

Join Human

Sign up now for a free Human account to get answers from specialists in Singapore.

Sign Up

Get The Pill

Be healthier with our Bite-sized health news straight in your inbox